1 Samuel 8: argument cards, questions, and answer key
Use your browser’s Print command to print or save as PDF. This worksheet works offline after download; external sources need a connection. Read the companion guide
Original Bibleward worksheet · BSB v5.9 observations paraphrased · Read 1 Samuel 8:1–22. This is an ancient narrative reading exercise, not voting advice. Keep personal political views out of shared answers; no response needs to be submitted.
Four completed cards
8:1–5 · Elders → Samuel. They cite his age and his sons’ conduct and request a king to judge them like other nations. The narrator has already reported the sons’ bribery and distorted justice.
8:6–9 · Samuel → the Lord; the Lord → Samuel. Samuel prays in displeasure. The Lord interprets the rejection as directed at his kingship and instructs Samuel to listen while warning the people.
8:10–18 · Samuel → the requesting people. His warning describes royal demands and the later plea for relief.
8:19–22 · People → Samuel → the Lord; the Lord → Samuel. They insist on a king to judge, lead, and fight. Samuel reports this; the Lord tells him to appoint a king. Samuel sends the people home.
Completed warning table
| Editorial category | Items in Samuel’s speech | Verses |
|---|---|---|
| Work and military service | Sons, commanders, farming, harvest, weapon and chariot equipment production | 8:11–12 |
| Household labor | Daughters working as perfumers, cooks, and bakers | 8:13 |
| Land and produce | Best fields, vineyards, olive groves; tenth of grain and grape harvest | 8:14–15 |
| Workers and animals | Servants, cattle, donkeys; tenth of flocks, using BSB wording | 8:16–17 |
| Consequences for the people | Becoming the king’s slaves; later appeal without an answer on that day | 8:17–18 |
The categories overlap. They are not modern legal classifications or a present-day tax calculation.
Eight questions
Who approaches Samuel in 8:4–5, and what two problems do they state? ____________________
What does Samuel do when displeased, and to whom does the Lord say the rejection is directed? ____________________
What two instructions does the Lord give Samuel in 8:9? ____________________
Choose one warning about labor and one about resources. Give each a verse. ____________________
What two things does Samuel say will happen in 8:17–18 beyond the taking of produce? ____________________
Which demand repeats in 8:5 and 8:20, and which royal functions appear in the final reply? ____________________
Does the people’s reply answer every warning with a counterargument? Explain what is and is not recorded. ____________________
Does chapter 8 name or install the new king? What actually happens at its close? ____________________
Answers with explanations
Israel’s elders approach Samuel. They say he is old and his sons do not follow his ways (8:4–5). The narrator specifically describes bribery and distorted justice in 8:3; distinguish that report from the elders’ wording.
Samuel prays to the Lord (8:6). The Lord says the rejection is of his own kingship, not merely of Samuel (8:7–8). Attribute that explanation to the Lord’s speech in the narrative.
Listen to their voice and solemnly warn them about the king’s conduct (8:9). Keeping both instructions avoids reading the final response as an unqualified endorsement of every demand.
Examples: sons serving the chariots (8:11), or daughters cooking (8:13); best fields taken (8:14), or a tenth of grain and grape harvest (8:15). Other entries from the completed table count if the verse supports them.
The people themselves will become the king’s slaves, and they will appeal for relief without receiving an answer from the Lord on that day (8:17–18). These are Samuel’s warnings; do not turn them into a prediction about a contemporary reader.
Resembling other nations repeats. The final reply wants a king to judge, lead, and fight their battles (8:19–20). It adds these functions rather than addressing each listed cost.
No item-by-item response is recorded. The narrator reports refusal to listen, and the people insist on a king (8:19–20). Their unspoken reasoning remains unstated.
No king is named or installed in this chapter. Samuel reports the people’s words, receives the instruction to appoint a king, and sends them home (8:21–22). Later events belong to later reading.
Worked correction and 120-word model
Overstatement: The warning must be withdrawn because a king is finally permitted.
Correction: The narrative gives both the warning and the final instruction. It does not say that Samuel retracts the warning. Check 8:10–18 alongside 8:21–22.
Israel’s elders approach Samuel because he is old and his sons do not follow his ways. They ask for a king like other nations have. Samuel is displeased and prays. The Lord tells him that the people have rejected divine kingship and instructs him to give a warning. Samuel describes a king taking people, produce, land, and animals for royal purposes. He also warns that they will later seek relief. The people refuse his warning and repeat their request, adding that their king should lead them and fight their battles. Samuel reports their words to the Lord. The Lord tells him to appoint a king, and Samuel sends the people home. The chapter ends before naming or installing that king.
Blank four-card set
| Range | Speaker → listener | Stated reason/request | Answer or consequence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8:1–5 | __________ | __________ | __________ |
| 8:6–9 | __________ | __________ | __________ |
| 8:10–18 | __________ | __________ | __________ |
| 8:19–22 | __________ | __________ | __________ |
One detail my first summary omitted: ____________________. One inference I should label rather than call a fact: ____________________. My next short reading: ____________________.
BSB 1 Samuel 8 · Berean permissions · Companion guide · Plans.
AI-assisted original reading resource; not Scripture or individual pastoral endorsement. Check the text, not your spiritual standing.